Paella, a classic Spanish rice dish, is the perfect meal to enjoy in the summer. Using sweet, buttery, sidestriped shrimp from Alaska elevates this recipe and makes it a great option for dinner under the stars. This recipe for grilled shrimp paella is not a traditional preparation, but it features some of paella’s signature elements — smoky flavors and great seafood.
Typically, paella is cooked in a thin, shallow pan over a burner that is specially designed for the dish. To adapt this recipe for an American grill, this paella is cooked as a few separate components. Short-grain rice is cooked in a heat-proof pan placed on the grill, allowing the base of the paella to infuse with smoky flavor. The addition of smoked paprika to the rice is essential in building up these flavors.
Meanwhile, summer veggies are grilled directly over the flame, while seasoned shrimp are cooked in foil packets until perfectly cooked through. The shrimp are also tossed in smoked paprika, which complements their sweetness. Each component of the paella is combined upon serving as a single plate of food.
Ingredients and Substitutions:
-
Short-grain rice: Look to buy a short-grain “paella rice” for this dish, which should have the right amount of starchiness and density to become perfectly chewy once cooked. Rice varieties like Bomba or Calasparra are ideal. If you’re not able to find these types of paella rice, an Italian risotto rice variety like Arborio can be substituted. Short-grain “sushi rice” can also work as a substitute.
-
Smoked paprika: Spanish “pimenton de la vera” is a smoked variety of paprika that is traditionally used in flavoring paella. However, in a pinch, any variety of paprika can be used, though the dish will not have as much smoky complexity.
-
Sidestriped shrimp: Wild-caught sidestriped shrimp are sweet and delicious, with a delicate texture that elevates this shrimp paella recipe. If substituting a different type of shrimp, make sure to choose a sustainably-sourced variety. Also keep in mind that the average grocery store shrimp is often treated with chemical additives like sodium tripolyphosphate, which can leave behind a rubbery texture once the shrimp is cooked. If possible, only purchase shrimp that hasn’t been treated with these chemicals.